Rate SWTOR out of 10.

[Kaptainne]

8/10 and I only go that low because I can envision it getting much better. I think they have started out with a great game but the potential is amazing, as long as they don't give in to the voices telling them to dumb it down as they go.

[Jeweledleah]

8/10 for now. I'm very much enjoying the game, I can see myself playing it for a long while. its not perfect. there are bugs. there are some improvements that could be added. as much as I adore this game, I cannot give it perfect score and remain objective. however. its been edging into 9 with recent patches. looking forward to what else is in store for us

[Lcore]

Lvl 1-10....9/10

lvl 10-20....8.5/10

lvl 20-30.....8/10

lvl 30-50......6/10

 

The magic started to disappear about lvl 30ish. The story had a great beginning and I was ready to embark on an epic journey; I expected to loose myself in another Bioware fantasy. Instead I got WoW quests with really good voice acting with a bunch of side quests.

 

So instead, I moved over and started to focus on PvPing with my buddies. This perhaps only pertains to me, but one of the most important things for me is the feeling of impact and the sound it makes when I hit. Hits were not as satisfying, nor were they instant or smooth. The mechanics were just alright and I eventually got bored of the warzones. It just didn't have the same magic as Arathi Basin or Twin Peaks, WoE from Ragnarok Online, or the epic Castle Sieges from Lineage 2, or RvR from DAOC.

 

I then tried raiding, the storyline wasn't as good as the early ones and the bosses were not as intuitive. I enjoyed Ro/L2 world bosses much more. I also enjoyed WoW/EQ2 raiding a lot more.

Edited January 11, 2012 by Lcore

[Gsup]

6/10 graphics and voice cut scenes look good

 

 

too many load screens not to mention instances/zones seems your playing by yourself

 

pvp is about as bad as you can get these days

[rjcain]

6.5/10

[Varedus]

8/10.

 

Reason: Still tons of bugs awaiting to be fixed as well as game is a little unstable at times, but typical for a new release. But still.. the rating sticks as for it is now.

[Gestas]

I give it an 8.7.

[Nerdwing]

I'd give it an 8.

[JeffNoble]

I would say 6. The questing has been fun at fulfilling at points but honestly, as has been mentioned before, something changed at 30. The GTN is a joke, the game BADLY needs an LFG mechanic of some kind. My brother has been at 50 for a week and I'm at 44 and we are both within an ace of hanging it up, at LEAST temporarily.

[stickyricky]

Leveling 9

End game 4, too many bugged fps

[Frostwyre]

This isn't a game that should get a seven or higher. Games that are finished and polished should. It does have awesome story and decent potential, but it's lacking a few key aspects earning it a 5.5/10 from me.

[PeacefulViolence]

9/10,

 

The game has huge potential, even as it currently stands it's better than any other MMO out there, once the bugs are fixed and the needed features are added in the game will be unstoppable.

[Mormack]

8.5/10

 

Fix a few bugs and it goes up a point...Just can't give a game a 10/10.

 

 

 

This isn't a game that should get a seven or higher. Games that are finished and polished should. It does have awesome story and decent potential, but it's lacking a few key aspects earning it a 5.5/10 from me.

 

You will never give an MMO above a 7 ever then at release. The way MMOs work is they release and fix later because the more you "Polish" the farther behind you get when compared to WoW. You can bet your dollar that if they had stalled release, WoW would have gotten even farther ahead with more features and then they would have to "polish" more before release. With an MMO its better to come out a little buggy and fix after launch than it is to try to polish to completion before hand because you will always be behind the curve of established MMOs. Its just the way the Market works.

Edited January 11, 2012 by Mormack

[Dajunka]

As I see it a year from today.

 

8/10

[Daonte]

7.2/10 atm, we'll see in a couple months.

[Ironspeed]

Cant give it one score so I'll give it two:

 

As a singel player RPG 9.5/10 (I'we dreamt about this since Kotor times!)

 

As a mmo: 4.5/10 what, wait it's a mmo?

[Hobnobb]

9/10 Great game with even greater potential.

[Gumakk]

leveling 9/10

end game 6/10-will be better soon

[Jswizzle]

10/10

 

My opinion is biased though because I loved Kotor, Dragon Age origins, and Mass Effect.

[Mormack]

Cant give it one score so I'll give it two:

 

As a singel player RPG 9.5/10 (I'we dreamt about this since Kotor times!)

 

As a mmo: 4.5/10 what, wait it's a mmo?

 

Its as much as an MMO as WoW is....Game definitely has more Group Quests lvling up than WoW does Currently.

[tyronechicken]

8/10 i guess

[bshardy]

8.5/10

 

The only real bugs are minor annoyances. For an MMO that just came out, it's amazing.

[Aaronblsr]

9/10

big fan i like the story line but the PVP let it down

[dembonez]

I would give it high marks as a single player game. Not so much an MMO. It reminds me of guildwars and a few other games combined. A mostly single player game with multiplayer aspects.

 

EDIT - Scores:

 

Single Player: 7-8/10

Multiplayer: 3-4/10

Edited January 11, 2012 by dembonez

[Papazooki]

I would give it high marks as a single player game. Not so much an MMO. It reminds me of guildwars and a few other games combined. A mostly single player game with multiplayer aspects.

 

EDIT - Scores:

 

Single Player: 7-8/10

Multiplayer: 3-4/10

 

I'll agree SWTOR is instanced a lot, but it is still very much an MMO.