I don't care about bugs. Every game, every piece of software on the planet has bugs.
I don't care about numbers of subscribers.
I don't care about the number of people in fleet.
I care that I can't explore worlds and that it's so completely linear.
I care that I have to listen to voice overs when it's a quest to kill 10 womp rats.
I care that I can't craft and harvest my own things.
People talk about sandbox vs. theme park, and I think that's the biggest issue to me. A theme park game, that is heavily instanced, simple doesn't give me the, "down the rabbit hole" feel. I'm just not immersed into it. I would play for maybe 20 minutes and just log off to do something else.
If BW can somehow expand the planets and change the crafting system, I might come back. It's not a horrible game, it's just designed wrong in my opinion.