PvP-wise, Guardians do suck, but it has nothing to do with the player. The best Guardian in the world could be 10x better at any other class. Period. I play the Guard to maximum efficiency and usually score top 5 in DPS/Medals/Protection. However, this takes a lot more work to achieve than other classes for the same end result. Statistically, the class is not worth playing -- at all. You think 200-400k damage is awesome, but a Sage can do that and put out 6-digit healing at the same time.