i just couldn't agree more

this is all based on my experiance on my serv. i'm not winning like 100% of the time.. 7/10 sometimes less sometimes more.. but i think taht we are vry capable of 1 vs 1 ;] still i might be playing against bads.. so my percepction might be bit off.. That being said.. we are nowhere near infli as far as pvp is concern.. Main problem with us is that we need too much time to get the dmg going..

not entirely true.. we have problems with the classes who can cleanse our DoTs that is othera Sins. Sages and Op if i recall correctly and i rather do not take 1 vs 1 against infli shadows.. sure if you tmie res so theirs FB and project so it won't hit you, you will win.. but this is so hard to do i'd rather don't play that rullet.. anywyas if you'll get you force strike proc in 1 vs 1 and you're not terrible you should win.. but gatting that proc it's different story entirely.. sometimes i not seem to get it.. (FB is on traget ;p) guess one of the problems why this spec is so dead..

let me stop you there sir.. balance shadows are very good at 1 vs 1. sure inli shadow sould kill us with ease. balance sages and some Op are troublesome.. but rest is kinda easy to 1 vs 1

well sins imho are underpreforming in general.. true but solorating is just based on statistics.. and statistically.. me and dog have 3 legs... so pls stop BS that solorating is a good way to measure someone's skill, becasue simply it isn't this is due to various variables which need to be taken into account and are totaly independent = meaning you as a player can not really affect them.. same may implay to group rating.. but there are far less variables which makes it far more accurate.. that being said.. imho best way to evaluate someone's skill is simply to play with them. you can't play with everyone... so only thing that is left is this rating system which just shows approximate skill.. better this than nothing i guess.. if you really believe tha this is accurate, please do.. you can believe what you want really but trying to convince somebody that they are wrong being wrong yourself is just bad..

perhaps somthing similar to infli.. Force Potency would give Force Strike proc that would help this spec alot....

sure but this works both ways... you might be that best player out there but still you're just good as rest of your team.. being match constantly with bads or pve guys your win/lose ration will be low... des it mean that your skill is low?

no, it is not.. your skill is only 25% of success.. (win) so 25% of your rating is your skill.. is it accurate then?

i think it has its uses.. especially against Op healers when they're trying to escape the inevitable;) i really like that talent and i'd like it to remain. and no, Spinning Strike is not enough for targets below 30% hp:cool:

as we you mean infli/deception right? coz balance/madness is not fine.. and no.. shadows/sins are not OP.. perhaps one spec is...

as far as I know that gives boost only to Force Technique's crit chance not Breach, nor any other DoTs... And believe me higher crit chance = higher survivability my two cents...

for max dps go.. 7/2/37 as far as crit i'm around 26,5 % with full buffs.. rest power gear stalker... power and crit relics.. you can swap crit for matrix cube.. aug willpower as for rotation.. FiB before dots.. rest is up to you. Use your brain and you'll be just fine ;] Balance sages do far more damage though..