Posted my reply in the other thread but I'll just copy and paste it here.
Absolutely has nothing to do with luck I am afraid.
"Unless you play on an empty server or you have a macro and/or a really good ping, you will never ever get that egg
After failing to pickup the egg and losing it to the same player (was just 2 of us at the spawn at Castle Panteer)6 times in a row, it felt like a lost cause.I Knew the spawn time down to second and was clicking at the spot a minute before the spawn time but with a ping of around 100ms there is simply no way that I can ever get that egg from the nest.
Ultimately, on a high population server, the more these macro farmers get the eggs and more of them compete with the selling with the resulting price drop with competition, you are better off just buying it, honestly.
Nothing else you can do really do about until they make it BOP."