So, I've read almost every thread (and every page) out there created on the whole warrior class/Sentinel QQ, as well as all the rebuttals. Here are the most common thoughts I could pull from them:
- Sentinels are weak at low levels, but gets better beyond 40
- Warrior class starts out strong, then gets **** beyond (pick one) level 20/40/at endgame
- JKs with the best gear can barely do Ilum
- JKs manage Ilum just fine
- Sentinels do no damage in PvP
- Sentinels tear through everyone like butter in PvP
As you can see, the opinions largely contradict one another. I myself have found contradictions with my own experience, as I have not had any problems with my Sent thus far, albeit I haven't gotten too far as of yet.
The thing is, we have so many people QQing and providing anecdotal evidence of how horrid their experience is, and then others who have a completely opposite experience for the better.
Given how much contradiction there is, I think this needs to be said...
L2P? Or prove me wrong
(Maybe I'll eat my own words in a few days )
*****UPDATE 1: 12/30/2011*****
I'm now on Alderaan, and I've also spent a few hours PvPing and gaining exposure to the other classes. I've also read the replies in this and other threads, and I have modified my stance a bit:
- Both sides, to a certain extent, are correct
- For a good chunk of folks, it certainly is a L2P issue. The Sentinel is more than playable, and can manage PvE solo. HOWEVER, it does take skill, and the feel of the class changes starting Tatooine. Essentially, the Sentinel can take 1 elite max, and tends to end with 20% or so health. Large pulls, or accidental pulls, or screw-ups in your rotation will lead to death.
- The Sentinel is indeed "underpowered". Not in the sense that the class in unplayable, but in the sense that the Sentinel is left in the dust by every other class, even in the hands of a good player.
- Lastly, Bioware does need to buff this class if we're going to be at all competitive in an endgame environment. We are the only class with a single role, besides Gunslinger: DPS. If we cannot pump out DPS that makes us shine compared to other classes, or at least be on par with them, then what would be our role in a raid? None.
TL;DR
Baddies will be bad?