Perusing these forums, I can't help but notice a preponderance of Jorgan haters. I'm quite fond of the cat man, and was trying to think of reasons he'd cause such animosity.
It simply can't be his usefulness as a companion. Unless you're soloing heroic stuff (and sometimes when you're soloing if you can kite things), Jorgan is the BEST for probably each AC and every spec. Dorne is for the lazies, and Jorgan is beefy enough and does so much damage that 4X and Vik are pretty useless in comparison. I only JUST got Yuun, who has a massive gear disadvantage on Jorgan at the moment, but who I could see at some point being as good. But even if you were to make the switch, after so many levels with Jorgan at your side, you have to feel a little affection for him!
So it must be his personality right? I guess he's kind of mean to you on Ord Mantell? Did he hurt your feelings? Jorgan doesn't care. Jorgan sees some hot shot rookie that everybody's fawning over? He's not impressed. And then the mission he sends you on gets messed up because the person you're supposed to be saving dies? Yeah he's pretty harsh here. My reaction: "EFF YOU MAN I'LL SHOW YOU HOW GOOD I AM."
It'd be one thing if Jorgan never acknowledges you, but you only have to keep playing through Ord Mantell for him to agree with you that you deserved to go with the rest of Havoc. And what does he do when Havoc mysteriously disappears? He disobeys an obviously suspect order and sends you in after them. If it were Dorne in that situation nobody would've known about the defection and the Empire would've gotten a pretty sweet bomb.
After that he takes his demotion pretty well, considering. He even offers you FRIENDLY advice about leading, which he actually has experience with - versus you who've been in Havoc about a week and are now it's CO. And even if you choose to get snappy at his pretty reasonable skepticism (which I did since I'm a BAMF and don't take no crap from no one), you can tell him to can it and he will without getting offended. And once you're off Coruscant he never questions you again, unless you don't promote him.
But why wouldn't you promote him? The most common answer I see is about Dorne's pants. Jorgan doesn't pull any punches about why he should be promoted: he deserved it back when he was originally an LT, and he deserves it even more now after being unjustly scapegoated and continuing to admirably serve the people that screwed him. He's not gonna list all the reasons he's made to be XO when you both already know them. Honestly, I didn't even know all this drama about Jorgan's promotion existed until I read a thread about it, since when Garza asked I didn't even talk about it, I promoted Jorgan immediately. And if Jorgan gives you crap later for promoting Dorne over him - you probably deserve it if your main reason was to get some ice-cold Imperial action. (Although I would appreciate seeing some ice-cold logic on why Dorne would deserve it over Jorgan.)
In conclusion, yay Jorgan. I'll love your grumpy-face even if no one else will.