In your opinion, this was also an underlying argument for the OP. It is certainly difficult to suggest that any mmo is better than the other because it is almost entirely based off the individual players wants and needs. Furthermore, when comparing mmo's you run into the problem of time. How can you possibly compare SWToR and WoW? 7 years of updates and patches went into WoW and it is no longer the game (not even close) it was on release. Comparing the two is as they say "like comparing apples and oranges". There are many things that SWToR had on release that WoW didn't have or still doesn't have. This would apply equally to any other mmo. It is safe to say that a good mmo is determined by the masses of individuals, if you will. Do you like it? If you don't remove yourself from the game there is no since in playing, that is the way of the mmo.