thread is dumb. if you wanted an open world pvp game, then you shouldnt be playing SWTOR? in most MMOs nowadays, everything is instanced because of all the tears, and people that want their game on easy mode.
personally i agree with the OP and i think open world pvp is the only way to go. warzones, pvp "games", and other instanced versions of pvp are incredibly lame, and have essentially killed pvp in mmos.
but everyone likes something different, you and me might enjoy different things (big shock i know). so instead of an all or nothing tear-a-thon, people should cry harder not about changing the existing system, but adding an alternative CHOICE of an open world pvp server.
successful MMOs all have 1 thing in common, they offer many choices. No company can go wrong by adding optional choices for players that want to play an mmo like they were playing back in 99-04
<3