Meh.
These two are full of crap. First of all, the format of the review is lame and restricting. Each author has to take a pro/con position regardless of their true opinion, so it's not an honest review.
Secondly, they're both wrong. This game is awesome! Yes, it plays like a story-driven single-player narrative in which I don't have to think and which I can occasionally share with other players. And that's just what I (and, by inference from the number of players, many of us) want. Well done, Bioware! This game rocks!
Plus, it has light sabers!!!
-Ozmar the Fanboy