GW2 has gotten a pass from almost the whole game and mainstream press. And when they occasionally don't only praise that game, GW2 fans gather like a swarm of locusts to figuratively beat down the hapless critic until the person has understood to keep silent.
The next saviour, considering Amalur's problem - another EA connected MMO, by the way - and how other challengers like DMO fall by the roadside, could well be Titan. Elder Scrolls Online is getting a lot of cr*p already, the SWTOR treatment from the permanently unhappy gamers, and everything else seems pretty marginal at best, including ArchAge etc.