I can agree with OP. I myself thinks that Jedi Knight is a good class. Both sentinel and Guardian. But when it comes to Counslar (Sage and Shadow), I feel that they split an iconic character in two in a bad way. When i play Sage I find the lack of melee disturbing but im amazed about the nice force abilities like Forcequake, telekinetic wave and disturbance. When i play Shadow i like the melee capabilities but hate the way it handels force abilities. Specing tank is not for me, infiltration and stealth is to much melee and Balance is based on dots (***?). I dont really care about dps numbers so its just how the classes is built up that bothers me. Anyways. I just go and play somthing else right? Cuz opinions is not alowed