Over all i think SWG was better. After or pre NGE. Because SWG was an open sand box, SWTOR is a linear game. A few other reasons are: 1. Space was sooo much better in SWG, no possible argument against it 2. There was real crafting in SWG, complex and diverse (remember how you gatherd resourses? and engineerd creatures?) 3. The maps/planets were much more imaginative, convincing and varied. And you could interact with the landscape. Build a city on it! You could even go fishing! 4. There were very different ways to play, you could even be a entertainer. The list goes on in detail. I think SWTOR is better only in story and combat mechanics. I enjoy SWTOR but no way can i play it for years! 3 months of SWTOR is enough unless you want to do all the side quests over and over again as you roll out new charectors just for the story. SWTOR is a really good game but it's not an MMOG because there is not much to do after the story ends.