I am a Valor 84 Assassin, and I have been running 27/1/13 darkness spec for PvP since valor 55. I have always used the shield generator instead of the power generator. The only difference between them is the ability to shield, and the stats. The power generator provides a lot more crit, and some willpower while losing endurance. I will agree with people here that Shield is not the best form of mitigation as it only affects white hits, but I disagree with the fact that you should not use shielding. With Dark Ward and Lightning Reflexes, you should definitely use a shield generator. While shields to not affect every hit like defense or armor, the white hits that are mitigated by shields helps a lot. It will vary by battle, but I think it is worth it in the long run to use a shield generator over the power generator. Everything else I wear is DPS PVP gear. Not only does shielding help with survivability, it also provides more Force from Lightning Reflexes, and thus increases DPS. There are not many ways to improve Force regen, so I try and utilize most of them.