Ok, yes free is always nice but I think the Free to play MMOR games need to shorten the Free Options and instead of charging $15, give tiered access at a cost of $5 per segment up to the $15 giving FULL access. Come on people, they need to make money or they don't keep going. Hell, people begging in SF get more than $5 per hour in the right areas.
The games should start as Free to Play with Uber Limitations. Enough play to let you feel the game, experience the art, see if it does seem like something you can have fun with. Then perhaps for $5, limit the zones you can get into, or something else. Something on the line of 25% access for the first $5, 50% for the second, and 100% access for the third. Then perhaps for an additional $5 per month, special stuff. like Bases/buildings that we can customize the build. Or Personal ships that we can design. Etc. All games should go this direction.
Additionally, if you loose your job or something, you should not loose your toons, BUT until you are paying again your limited in what you get to do. YOu don't LOOSE what you had, you just don't have access to it all.
We need to pay to play so that the games continue giving great service. Great Art, and continually grow and develop.