Pretty much, and it's nothing about the way you play. You can be as dedicated as you like, but the games mechanics are stacked against you. You can line up one yellow damage heavy hitter during your precision+zen window, and it's fantastic in short fights, but no where near frequent enough to compete with other specs vs longer fights.
Can you raid with combat/carnage? Sure you can, but today's player base is impatient and all glued to whatever numbers starparse is putting out. Any time there's a wipe they'll all blame you first "I don't think we have enough dps for this".