I've noticed another wierd thing since yesterday's launcher update and server downtime: I'm now at 500/1000 on planetary conquest achievements, despite having never conquered half those planets.
The Balmora, Taris, Quesh, Rishi and Yavin achievements have been fulfilled somehow. Obviously, I haven't received the corresponding planetary conquest titles, since our guild never finished first on those planets.
It seems to be the same for other guild members. How about people on other servers?
As far as granting the rewards post facto goes, I received the rewards on a character that did not even exist during said conquest... So they did not even create a script to grant them, they seem to be doing so by hand, and poorly. Figures...
I'm done with them. They're not getting any more money until they sort themselves.