This is tricky. I have allso tendency of playing "grey" characters. I don't try to do it, but eventually things just turn up so that my alligment is more or less grey... Sometimes it is 1/3 dark 2/3 light and sometimes 2/3 dark 1/3 light and everything between those two "extremes" I can see 3 possible solutions 1) grey items and grey story path (calculate total dark and light points together) 2) a little bit of both... You can wear both light and dark side items, but not the absolutely extremes so you could get level 4 dark and level 1 light items or opposite dependin on your light dark totals or something betveen them (so the total level would be 5 at maximum (most balanced option without tweaks...)) 3) Only absolutes (only 100% dark or 100% good) so one desision can chance you from pure dark to pure light... Like Darth vader did at the end of movie) I don't like this option much... It does not make a lot of sence. I thin personally IMHO that Darth Vader was on the edge (not totally evil any more 4500 ligh 5500 dark) and was pushed from darknes to the light (6000 ligh 4000 dark by the influence of Luke) But even that does not make much sense IMHO 4) Total balance (5000/5000) would allow level 5 grey items, 1000 light and 9000 dark would allow level 1 light items, level 1, grey items and level 4 dark items, 3000 light 7000 dark woul allow level 2 light side items, level 3 grey items and level 3 dark side items, 4001 light side and 5999 dark side woul allow level 2 light side, level 4 grey side and level 2 dark side items... or something similar It would reguire some balancing though. (And yes I can't calculate ;-)