Ive pugged plenty of games. I have almost full champ gear, and im rank 39. The problem is that once everyone figures out that all you have to do to win is spec heals and focus on 1 person, there is nothing you can do to stop capping.
And even pre-made vs. pre-made doesnt solve the fact that one team type will always win- thus the game is decided by who gets the ball 1st, and maybe who has the better geared tank.
Obviously pvp is about more than just rofl damage in the mid, but it has gone so far, that dealing damage to the tank does nothing. I have 10% bonus from expertise, almost 700 bonus damage to force powers, and I hit tanks for 200 a pop? which is taken care of by less than one HOT. Never mind the fact that the team has 4-5 dedicated healers on him.