Haha, can totally relate to that. I never got around to finishing my evil Shepard.

I heard that doesn't make much difference http://www.swtor.com/community/showthread.php?t=53235

I was looking for something along these lines. I constantly find myself making choices that I think are evil, but turn out to be good/neutral and vice-versa. Especially with the smuggler and bounty-hunter classes (not so much with Jedi Knight, where I think the boundaries are much more clear-cut)