Once again I like your point. Although again I must question you. It WOULD matter depending on which Jedi you were asking. We don't know if Obi knew Padmé was alive or not. All we DO know is that he felt that the right thing to do was to capture Dooku, in order to save a much larger amount of life. And a look at how Anakin's life turned because he wanted to save someone, ONE life he cared a bit to much for. Fallen. And about Revan. We don't really know if it's actually him. If it is indeed the real one (which I would love) I wouldn't say he is fallen. He is both light and dark, because of that he possess enormous wisdom and knowledge. He is returning with both Sith and Rep forces with him. I wouldn't say fallen. I'd say most bad *** dude in all SW.

Well, I get your point! BUT, we are talking about saving ONE life and in exchange jeopardize the entire galaxy, if not the universe. AND saving her/ or him means that you have formed some form of attachment, which IS forbidden for Jedi. Regardless weather Obi knows Padmé is alive or not, he also points out to Anakin, if they should capture Dooku at that moment the war might have ended right there. "We have a job to do [...] what do you think Padmé would do if she were in your position?" - Obi. "She would do her duty"- Ani.

That was exactly my first thought aswell, the "cloud your judgement" part.

I'll remember that mate! Yes I agree, IF you are presented with two choices the outcome should effect you. I would have liked very much to have seen the game work that way, and I can tell you that he is probably nerfed since then. I remember the difference in the smuggler story Beta vs Vanilla.

You present an interesting point mate! Loved reading it!

Greetings people. Yesterday I finished my Jedi knight story line, ( yes I know, rather late dude...) anyway I came across something interesting; Before you enter the Emperors Throne room you are presented with a dilemma. Your padawan Cira is in trouble and might die. Your choises are: Save her; Im such a hero Don't save her; I have to defeat the Emperor for the greater good of the galaxy. Now if you diside to save her you get light side points, its something "good" to do. If you go on with your misson to defeat the Emperor WHO has the power to devour the entire universe, that gives you dark side points, its a "bad thing to do". My point is that the light side choise goes against everything a Jedi is. "Don' t ler your personal feelings get in the way" - obi wan lectures Anakin, end of episode II. So does the game mean that obi wan is the most evil Jedi out there? Or that the ideal Jedi is a Anakin who does not turn to the dark side? Please post your thoughts and arguments I find this very interesting! May the force be with you all!