As a former wow player, b4 and after the dungeon finder, I see ups and downs. But I do ultimately support a dungeon finder. ups: Quick groups (almost instant if you are a tank) All business (run dungeon, get loot, get out) Mostly overgeared people running dailies Downs: Not Noob Friendly No communication (no friending) No consequences for ninja looting or being a baddie Member kicking doesn't work People quit and leave groups easily I'm in a large guild consisting of 300+ members. Reason for joining this guild? Another channel to spam LFG. It sucks how there isn't a global lfg channel. My server pop only has 120-190 ppl on the republic fleet at a time. I spent 1hr + just trying to set up a group for Maelstrom Prison. 30minutes to get a heals and 1 dps. Nearly 25minutes spamming to find 1 extra dps.... DPS!!!! took a 15minute break and attempted again for another 30 minutes. I would like BW to learn from Blizz and improve and create a better dungeon finder. Do not enable cross server partying. Make it easily to group without messing with the community overall.