great info thanks, these two post have tons of arguments on the subject and is very informative.

true... but it was party and Guild he got booted from. oh well thanks for the convo guys it was informative

yeah he just told me he rubbed it in a bit when after the guy got the 2nd set of gloves by by saying "see don't be sad you got some gloves." So i can get the guy getting mad and booting him. But, personally I am a smart *** and would've talked way more **** if the guy was whining over gloves so i would have got booted for sure.... but thats just me.

I don't think he did so I can see him being in the wrong there but why boot the guy?? They are Items, its a game, there are millions of them everywhere I get an orange item like every time I complete a quest and i give them away to my guild for free they don't matter. I just think if it was completely random how items were given out to a party then things like that wouldn't happen. It would save headaches.

great Point Scorpienne thanks

It was just an example. What about Str/ End mods on Heavy to a medium guy then to make it more correct

Not true my roommate actually got booted from a Casual PvE guild in the middle of a FP by some guy over gloves cause they were light and he choose Need for Kira. To make it even worse while the guy was ************ about him picking need for his comp they got another set of light gloves with basically the same specs. He's been mad for a day about this, thats why i started this thread. Oh further update my roommate may have asked for it a bit by saying "see don't be sad" after that guy got the 2nd set of light gloves

Good to know thanks guys, its kinda a BS system though wouldn't it be better if every item rolled for the same for everyone. On 2nd thought i do have a etiquette question, what if u can use the mods in an item but not the item itself how would you choose there Need or Greed? for example if u see heavy armor that has great mod upgrades for endurance and power but you are a jedi and can only wear medium how would you guys roll.

so my question to everyone is, does selecting Need or Greed really affect how you roll for an Item?? This isn't a post about Need Vs Greed etiquette just so everyone knows, I mainly want to know what selecting one or the other does to your Roll. Thanks