[Does Anyone Like Sgt. Rusk? (some spoilers)]

My personal take on Sgt Rusk is that I brought him along because he's evidently deranged, and I was going to somehow try and heal his disordered mind through the Force.

[Episode 7 worries...]

As far as the rendering post RotJ EU non-canon goes, I'm not overly bothered; it's worth remembering that EU always was, according to GL, 2nd class canon next to the movies anyway(which also goes for the novelizations of the movies; they are interpretations of the source - the movies themselves).

Never forget, a wise man(or should that be wise guy?) once said "a great many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our point of view".

[Watch in what order? 4,5,6,1,2,3 vs 1-6]

Watch 4,5,6 then try 1,2,3.

 

If I tried 1,2,3,4,5,6 then I'd probably give up around haflway through 2.

[Way too much CC!?]

Exactly, and remove knockbacks ffs...or limit it to 1 class having it...

 

No, we need MOAR KNOCKBACKS. How else can a trooper play Sith tennis properly?

[A look at PvP Now and in 3 Months from Now]

lol.

 

I was in a wz a couple of days ago where there was me(sentinel), 5 other sentinels, a guardian and a vanguard.

[Why are we not getting more varied pets and mounts ?]

I don't really expect games to launch with hundreds of mounts and non-combat pets. It's not really a core feature but rather something that is added over time.

 

So maybe just be a little patient?

 

This. People mention *that other game* as if it's always had a metric ****-ton of mounts and pets.

[Deny it if you will, but you'll watch EPI in 3D]

I'll deny it all I like, because I won't go and see it in 3d.

[Star Wars vs WH40K]

Also dont forget a space marines organs and metabolism. They have 2 hearts. Their flesh repairs itself. Their blood coagulates in seconds.... Even sticking a lightsabre (on the off chance it could penetrate their armour) in a space marine would probably not kill him... So whilst the jedi is wondering why the space marine hasnt gone down yet during his backswing.... he gets a power claw or power fist to the face.

 

Actually, none of a Space Marine's alterations would really save him from having a lightsaber jammed into him.

Just like any other organic, the water in his organs would flash boil(the lightsaber having a temperature roughly what you'd have experienced at ground zero in Hiroshima), so even though his blood would clot quickly, he'd still have been cooked.

[in defense of the prequels]

The galatic sanate put taxes on there trade route's wich cost them alot of money.

They blockade naboo as a blackmail tool.

 

As for why naboo i dont of know offical reson.

Meaby it was rich in resourse meaby it was out of the way who know's.

 

Unofficaly darth sidous wanted them too.

Tho we could argue for hours how they got in lugue with the sith.

 

And what exactly did the Trade Federation have to do with the Seperatists, then?

[Anyone think that the EU has lost its way?]

To the guy that says that Star Wars are all about good, happy endings. Maybe in a long run and still it can be read in different ways but just looking at the movies:

 

EP 1 - happy ending

EP 2 - grim ending

EP 3 - grim ending

EP 4 - happy ending

EP 5 - grim ending

EP 6 - happy ending

 

So yea happy, good always triumphs my ***. And what would be a problem if a new star wars movie was made and the antagonist would be vanquished by protagonist using the dark side?

 

You're ignoring the fact that those 6 movies are just one story - that of the rise, fall and redemption of Anakin Skywalker. That story has a happy ending.

LotR has something similar - the edning of the Fellowship isn't exactly all happy-clappy, and neither is that of the Two Towers.

[who is stronger superman or a jedi?]

What if the Jedi had a lightsaber with a kryptonite crystal?

[Why do people give MVP to the worst player.]

OP, the worst player does NOT get the MVP votes.

I know, because I never get any.

[If 90% of the classes would be melee fighter...]

Yes I have paid attention.

 

Also when Order 66 was put in place troopers smashed Jedi like flys.

 

Jango also just shoots Jedi dead.

 

 

One thing I've noticed about Star Wars Lore. The volume of Jedi/Sith is inversly propertional to their power. In other words, when there are 10 or 20 forces users in existence they rock, but when there are thousands they always grow weak.

 

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ConservationOfNinjutsu

["INC LEFT" That is not a good way to call INCs]

It works fine in any group I've been in. The limiting factor is people staying to cream the last couple of enemies where they are instead of moving, not the format of the call.

[First Contact with an alien race from TOR: who would you pick?]

That'd be a waste in my opinion, surely they'd have knowledge that'd benefit humanity which would be more useful than just using them as slaves. Plus slavery is evil

 

If they were slaves, then we'd have all their knowledge and expertise. Slaves aren't just for picking cotton.

[Order 66 T_T]

I don't think it's that simple, not when you factor in the Clone Wars series.

 

These Jedi have worked alongside their troops for, in some cases, YEARS. I can see getting blindsided by the Order 66 event, even if just for a few seconds.

 

Now, should they have been suspicious of the incredibly convenient clone army at the start? Absolutely, but by the time the betrayal comes, I could see all but the most pessimistic and suspicious Jedi being caught at least a little unaware.

 

Then again, IITS -- It's In The Script. The Jedi were caught flatfooted and slaughtered because they had to be in setting the stage for "A New Hope."

 

Want to really get depressed? Aside from Anakin, Windu, and the other members of the Council that went to arrest Palpatine (since they directly opposed him, or in Anakin's case at least was there for the event), all those Jedi killed by their troops were still loyal to the Republic and likely died never knowing why they were being killed.

 

It's sad to see, but you're right, there were so many precautions that could have been taken.

 

Hell, I often wonder why the Republic didn't just let the Separatists LEAVE. Better to see worlds leave the Republic at the stroke of a pen in some kind of treaty recognizing them as their own soverign entity than through years of bloody civil war.

 

Take it and run,

 

You answered it yourself - IITS. Maybe, like Kazahkstan, one of the Seperatist worlds if the greatest exporter of potassium, and all other worlds have inferior potassium?

[Star Wars vs WH40K]

Well, you'd likely still be in-system after weeks at sublight, since you can't accelerate too fast with all those squishy organics on board.

[Why do Anakin and Padme love each other?]

"This is the ***** you're looking for" - Anakin to Padme

[Remake the Original Trilogy]

I'd prefer them to remake 1-3 without George first.

And also without the plot that was used for them.

[First Contact with an alien race from TOR: who would you pick?]

What a waste, i'd rather have a good species we can integrate in to earth's culture rather than just one that people want to punch in the face

 

We can use them as slaves too.

[Star Wars vs WH40K]

Odd. Back in the day, even the most advanced ships in 40k couldn't make the transition to warp space near a planetary body. IIRC, it took several weeks of sublight travel to go from orbitting an earth-sized planet to a safe jump point.

[First Contact with an alien race from TOR: who would you pick?]

Gungans, so I can punch one in the face.

[Knockbacks]

Knock bakcs are fun. Annoying when you're the one being booted into fire/acid/hole in the Voidstar. Bun fun as hell when you do it to someone else.

I like to yell 'FORE' when I do it.

[Petition: REMOVE THE NEED TO WIN FOR PVP QUESTS]

Maybe replace it with a points system. Each win gets you 10 points, losing gets you 1. You need 30 for the daily quest.

And if you turn in 30 points of fail, then the game laughs at you.

[10-49 do medals matter?]

"'Hans Olo?' Gimme a break".

 

"Mine just says 'Partcipant'".