I liked it. a lot actually.
Only thing that bothered me on theater was the feel that ppl will whine about similarities to EIV
(but then again i dont mind about others opinnions that much so even that is ok )
Liked the "realistic" good guys, flawed and even childish bad guy, struggling if "i have what it takes" to do really bad things and break free. I didn't like the way some ppl just went "total bad from total good" before (i'm more of an 50 shades of force type of guy)
and mixing R2-D2 to Jar Jar and get a near perfect komedian who still wasn't annoying...
Some bad, lot more good 4/5
Let's see what second view brings